Feelin’ Low: P Bass vs Jazz Bass

Home » Blog » Gear » Feelin’ Low: P Bass vs Jazz Bass

Hey there, bass enthusiasts! Ever found yourself torn between the famous Fender Precision Bass (P Bass) and the Fender Jazz Bass (J Bass)? Curious about their unique features, history, and the legendary musicians who’ve played them? You’re in the right place. This comprehensive guide will explore the characteristics, strengths, and tonal qualities of these two iconic bass guitar models.

By getting to know their differences in design, tone, and practical applications, you’ll be ready to make a choice that suits your musical style and playing technique. So, let’s buckle up for an exciting low-end journey and dive into the world of P Bass vs Jazz Bass.

Introduction to P Bass and Jazz Bass

As a bass player, you’ve probably heard of the Fender Precision Bass (P Bass) and the Fender Jazz Bass (J Bass).

These two iconic bass guitar models have shaped the sound of popular music and have been used by numerous famous bassists throughout history. Each has its unique characteristics, strengths, and tonal qualities, making them suitable for different musical styles and playing techniques.

Brief History of P Bass

The Fender Precision Bass, also known as the P Bass, was introduced in 1951. It was designed to overcome the limitations of the upright bass, such as size and volume. The P Bass features a solid body, a split-coil pickup, and a 20-fret maple neck. It quickly gained popularity, especially in rock ‘n roll and country music, for its deep, punchy tone and strong low-end presence. The P Bass is known for its simplicity and reliability, with a straightforward control layout and a single pickup.

Brief History of Jazz Bass

The Fender Jazz Bass, also known as the J Bass, was introduced in 1960 as a complement to the Precision Bass. It was initially named the Deluxe Model, but was later renamed the Jazz Bass to appeal to jazz musicians. The Jazz Bass features a sleeker, offset waist body design, two single-coil pickups, and a 20-fret rosewood or maple fingerboard. Over the years, there’ve been various updates to the Jazz Bass, including different neck profiles, fingerboard materials, and pickup configurations. The Jazz Bass is known for its versatile tone, with a brighter and more articulate sound compared to the Precision Bass.

The Significance of The P Bass and Jazz Bass in Music

Both the Precision Bass and Jazz Bass have played significant roles in shaping the sound of popular music. They’ve been used in various genres and have become iconic instruments in their own right.

The Precision Bass is often associated with the driving basslines of rock ‘n roll and heavy rock, while the Jazz Bass is known for its versatility and ability to adapt to different musical styles.

The core differences between the P Bass and Jazz Bass lie in the neck, body shape, and pickups. The P Bass has a thicker neck and a wider nut width, which some players find more comfortable for playing with their fingers. The Jazz Bass has a slimmer neck and a narrower nut width, which some players find more comfortable for playing with a pick. The P Bass typically has a split single-coil pickup, which provides a deep, punchy tone. The Jazz Bass typically has two single-coil pickups, which provide a brighter, more versatile tone.

Notable Musicians Using P Bass and Jazz Bass

The Precision Bass and Jazz Bass have been used by many legendary bassists. Notable P Bass players include James Jamerson, John Entwistle, and Dee Dee Ramone, who are known for their punchy tones and solid foundation in the band mix. On the other hand, the Jazz Bass has been favored by bassists like Jaco Pastorius, Marcus Miller, and Geddy Lee, who value its clarity, articulation, and ability to cut through the mix.

In addition to these legendary players, many other notable bassists have used either the P Bass or the Jazz Bass. These include Reggie Workman, Niels-Henning Ørsted Pedersen, Stanley Clarke, Eberhard Weber, Gary Peacock, Ron Carter, Dave Holland, Charlie Haden, Christian McBride, and Larry Grenadier. Each of these musicians has brought their unique approach to the instrument, further expanding the possibilities of bass playing.

When choosing between the Precision Bass and Jazz Bass, it ultimately comes down to personal preference and the specific needs of the player. Some bassists prefer the simplicity and powerful tone of the Precision Bass, while others appreciate the versatility and clarity of the Jazz Bass. It’s recommended to try out both instruments and see which one feels and sounds best for your playing style and musical preferences.

A close up image of troy sanders playing his p bass.

Source: Fender

Specifications and Design

Size and Shape of P Bass

The P Bass has a symmetrical body shape with a traditional body radius, constructed from alder and finished with a gloss polyester. This design contributes to its harder-edged sound with more sustain.

Its neck, made of maple, has a “Modern C”-shaped profile and a smooth back finish. The fingerboard is pau ferro, with a 9.5″ radius, 20 medium jumbo frets, and white dot position inlays. The nut, made of synthetic bone, has a width of 1.625″. The scale length is 34″.

Size and Shape of Jazz Bass

The J Bass, on the other hand, has an offset body shape with an asymmetrical lower bout. The body is hand-shaped to original specifications, with a gloss polyester finish.

The neck is narrower at the nut compared to the P Bass, with a “Modern C” neck profile for comfort and performance. The fingerboard is also made of Pau Ferro, with a 9.5″ radius, 20 medium jumbo frets, and white dot position inlays. The nut is synthetic bone, with a width of 1.5″. The scale length is also 34″.

Material and Build of P Bass

The P Bass is equipped with a Player Series split-coil Precision Bass middle pickup, with master volume and tone controls. The hardware finish is nickel/chrome, with standard open-gear tuning machines, a 4-saddle standard bridge, and a 4-bolt neck plate with an “F” logo. The pickguard is 3-ply parchment, and the control knobs are knurled flat-top. The strings are Fender USA 7250M Nickel Plated Steel.

Material and Build of Jazz Bass

The J Bass is equipped with two single-coil pickups, with two pole pieces per string, allowing for a wider range of tonal options. The hardware includes a 4-saddle bridge for enhanced tuning stability and punchy attack, standard open-gear tuning machines, and a 4-bolt standard neck construction. The control knobs are vintage-style black plastic Jazz Bass knobs. The strings are also Fender USA 7250M nickel-plated steel.

The main distinction between the P Bass and the J Bass is the pickup configuration, which gives each bass its unique sound. The P Bass has a more focused tone, while the J Bass has a more articulate tone. The choice between a P Bass and J Bass comes down to personal preference and the specific sound and feel that you’re looking for. Both basses have their own unique characteristics and can be used to achieve a wide range of tones.

Tone and Playability

Tone Qualities of P Bass

The P Bass is renowned for its robust, resonant sound. The neck pickup contributes to the richness of the tone, softening its sharpness. Increasing the volume of this pickup results in a more resonant and profound sound, while the bridge pickup captures higher, thinner frequencies, adding a sharpness and punch to the tone.

The tone knob on a P Bass manipulates the overall brightness or darkness of the signal. A fully turned tone knob results in a more vibrant sound, while reducing the tone knob gives a warmer and deeper feel to the sound.

Tone Qualities of Jazz Bass

The J Bass is recognized for its balanced tone, enhanced sharpness, and the ability to deliver a light, airy sound. The single-coil pickups on a J Bass provide an open sound with rich top-ends. They emphasize treble and enhance sharpness and definition, while also harmonizing both frequencies to capture the natural sound of the strings.

Contrary to popular belief, J Bass pickups don’t lack bottom-end, but rather focus on emphasizing treble frequencies. The J Bass has two volume controls and one tone control, allowing for more complex blends of the pickups.

Playing Technique for P Bass

The P Bass is often the go-to for slap bass players due to its bright and articulate tone, which enhances the “snap” and “popping” tones of slap bass playing. Slap bass players often prefer to increase the volume of the neck pickup on a P Bass to achieve a bright and defined tone. The P Bass has one split single coil pickup, which sounds warm and full with more low-end emphasis. The split single coil pickup is wired in series, creating a hum-cancelling effect and reducing buzz. The P Bass has one volume control and one tone control, making adjustments straightforward.

Playing Technique for Jazz Bass

The J Bass is celebrated for its versatility and is suitable for various playing techniques. The balanced tone and enhanced attack of the J Bass make it a great fit for fingerstyle jazz and funk playing. You can adjust the volume and tone settings on a J Bass based on your personal preference and the desired style of playing. The J bass has two single coil pickups, which sound brighter and clearer with more treble emphasis. The bridge pickup on the J bass sounds brighter and hotter than the neck pickup, providing tonal variety. The J bass will have more buzz and hum when using only one pickup.

Mikey Way playing a jazz bass on stage.

Source: Fender

Practical Applications

Ideal Music Genres for P Bass

The P Bass has found its niche in genres such as rock, punk, metal, and blues. Its robust, resonant sound lends itself well to these styles, providing a sturdy rhythmic backbone.

Ideal Music Genres for Jazz Bass

The J Bass, on the other hand, is a favorite among jazz, funk, R&B, and fusion musicians. Its brighter tone and midrange presence, coupled with a slimmer neck profile for faster playing, make it a fitting choice for genres that demand complex bass lines and a more pronounced bass role.

When to Use P Bass in a Mix

In a mix, the P Bass excels when a robust, rhythmic foundation is needed. Its resonant, focused sound can provide a steady bass layer that blends well with other elements without necessarily taking center stage.

When to Use Jazz Bass in a Mix

Conversely, the J Bass is often chosen when the bass needs to cut through the mix with clarity and definition. Its midrange presence allows for detailed, articulate bass lines, making it a suitable choice for mixes where the bass plays a more melodic role or needs to hold its own against other dominant elements.

The choice between a P Bass and a J Bass hinges on your personal taste, the musical context, and the desired tone and playing style. Both basses have distinct characteristics and can shine in different genres and mix situations. It’s advisable to test both basses in person to determine which one aligns with your individual preferences.

Conclusion: Choosing Between P Bass and Jazz Bass

Considerations for Beginner Musicians

For novices, the P Bass might be more approachable due to its wider neck and string spacing, which aids in muting unplayed strings. Its battery-free operation and uncomplicated tone settings also make it less daunting. Conversely, the J Bass, with its slimmer neck, could be more suitable for younger players or those with smaller hands. Its suitability for slapping techniques might also appeal to some beginners.

Considerations for Professional Musicians

For seasoned players, the choice between a P Bass and a J Bass could depend on the genre of music you specialize in and the specific sound you’re seeking. The P Bass is often the instrument of choice in rock and punk music, while the J Bass is frequently preferred in funk, jazz, and metal. The J Bass also offers a wider range of tonal possibilities with its dual pickups and multiple EQ knobs.

Considerations Based on Personal Preference

Your individual preference is a significant factor in deciding between a P Bass and a J Bass. The P Bass, with its balanced body shape and substantial neck profile, might be more comfortable for some. The J Bass, with its asymmetrical body shape and slimmer fretboard, offers a distinctive aesthetic and feel. It’s also slightly heavier than the P Bass due to its denser lower bout. The instruments used by your musical idols might also influence your decision.

The Versatility of P Bass and Jazz Bass

Both the P Bass and the J Bass are adaptable instruments that can cater to a variety of genres. However, they each have their unique attributes. The P Bass is often chosen for music styles that require a broad tonal range, while the J Bass is popular among fingerstyle and slap players due to its precision, making it a flexible choice for a diverse array of music styles.

Fender provides a range of P Bass and J Bass models, including Squier models for beginners and American-made models for professionals. Other manufacturers like G&L, Lakland, Ibanez, and Sire also produce P Bass and J Bass-style instruments. The decision between a J Bass and a P Bass ultimately hinges on your personal preference and the sound you’re striving for.

Final Thoughts

So, when the show’s over and the lights go out, choosing between the P Bass and Jazz Bass comes down to one thing – what you prefer. Your musical style, how you play, and the kind of tone you like all play big parts in this decision. You might find the P Bass appealing if you’re into rock-n-roll, with its deep, punchy tones. On the other hand, if you’re a jazz player, the Jazz Bass might hit all the right notes for you with its brighter and articulate sound.

Both the P Bass and Jazz Bass have made their mark in the music world, contributing significantly to a wide range of genres. Knowing their unique characteristics and tonal capabilities, you’re in a good position to make a choice that fits your music style and playing technique.

Andrew Scrivens

Andrew Scrivens

I am a live musician and guitar teacher from Brisbane, Australia, with extensive experience playing live, in the studio and for TV shows. I play in many venues, studios, music shops and with my students and as such am exposed to a lot of different gear. I form my opinions based on my experiences playing instruments in these locations.

*This site contains product affiliate links. We may receive a commission if you make a purchase after clicking on one of these links. However we have provided our unbiased, honest, and professional opinions of all products that we review.